History Optional Paper-1 Solution – 2015: Q.2 (c)

History Optional Paper-1 Solution – 2015: Q.2 (c)

2(c)”Archaeology knows of no Aryans; only literature knows of Aryans.” Examine critically.


The composers of the Rig Veda described themselves as Arya. The Vedic literature talks about the political life ,the social life, the economic life and the religious life of the Aryans. The texts also deal in details about the gods and goddesses of the Aryans and the assemblies like sabha and samiti. It also mentions cattle rearing, agricultural activity, crafts like cart making, carpentry, metal working etc as their main occupations.

There are also references in the Rig veda to various kind of forts, attacks on walled cities, and the epithet  Purandara (destroyer of forts) given to the god Indra but the archaeological records do not point towards any such wars and destruction.

But there do  exist archaeological evidences which point towards settlement of the people in the north-west and north India during the vedic age:

(1) The family books of the Rig Veda  samhita refers to the land of sapta-sindhu or the seven rivers that is the Indus, its five tributaries, and the saraswati(Ghaggar-Hakra) which still exist except the saraswati which disappeared.

(2)The Painted grey ware has a very extensive distribution, stretching from Himalayan foothills to the Malwa plateau in central India, and from the Bahawalpur region of Pakistan to Kaushambi near Allahabad in Uttar Pradesh. However, The main distribution of the sites are in the Indo-Gangetic divide, Sutlej basin and upper Ganga plains.

(3)The important evidence for the PGW material culture is available from excavated sites such as Hastinapur, Alamgirpur, Ahichchtra, Allahpur, Mathura, Kampil etc. The structural remains at the sites consist of wattle and daub and mud huts, baked and unbaked bricks, artefacts of stone, bone and terracotta.A fire altar has also been found at Jakhera.

(4)The iron objects have also been found and evidence of cultivation of rice, wheat and barley is also available. Bones of cattle, sheep and pigs have been discovered. Horse bones have been found at Hastinapur.

Based on the above mentioned archaeological evidences it would be incorrect to say that ”Archaeology knows of no Aryans”.

Posted from WordPress for Android

2 Comments Add yours

  1. siddharth says:

    the purandhara point can be taken into consideration. but old ncert says that we can not identify forts held b pre aryans only few in afghanistan. and all rest of your points makes no direct reply to answers, very vague. please explain sir.
    nios uses this line directly in 4.2 MIGRATION OF THE ARYANS- archaeological evidence of migrations comes from what is known as andronovo culture situated in southern siberia. this culture flourished in second millenium bc. from here people moved to north of hindukush( the are known as bacteri- margiana archaeological complex) and from here they entered india.
    reply asap sir
    help me score in my mains


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s